Cake Menu

Contact us to place a cake order. We require a minimum of two days notice. We accept rush orders for next day or same day delivery with an additional fee, based on the order. Each cake is made fresh to order for local New York City delivery or pick-up. Monday through Saturday, 9am to 6pm.

Serving Size

Cakes are five layers high, except for mini cakes which are three layers high:

  • 3 inch Mini Cake serves 1 to 3 - $18; 3 layers high 
  • 6 inch serves 8 - $75.00
  • 8 inch serves 16 - $100.00
  • 10 inch serves 30 - $145.00
  • 12 inch serves 45 - $180.00 

Allswell 1st Birthday Cake

Crumbless funfetti cake with whipped cream filling, white chocolate ganache and rose gold sprinkles

Chocolate Mint Chip

Chocolate cake with mint chocolate chip buttercream and dark chocolate ganache


Classic white almond cake with vanilla buttercream, homemade raspberry jam and white chocolate ganache 


Five layers of colorful vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream, dark chocolate ganache and sprinkles


Vanilla sprinkles cake with vanilla buttercream and white chocolate ganache

Black & White

Brownie cake alternating with vanilla cake, vanilla and chocolate buttercreams and dark chocolate ganache

Red Velvet

Classic red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting and white chocolate ganache

Banana Peanut

Banana cake with chocolate peanut butter frosting and milk chocolate ganache

Chocolate Truffle

Chocolate sponge cake with chocolate buttercream and dark chocolate ganache

Chocolate Chip Salted Caramel

Chocolate chip pound cake with salted caramel buttercream and salted caramel glaze

Lemon Berry

Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream, fresh berries, lemon curd and white chocolate ganache

Cookies n’ Cream

Vanilla cake swirled with homemade Oreos, vanilla buttercream and dark chocolate ganache

Key Lime Pie

Lime-scented vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream, lime curd and graham cracker crumble 

Carrot Cake

Classic carrot cake with walnuts, cream cheese frosting and salted caramel glaze

Gluten-Free Vanilla 

Vanilla gluten-free cake with vanilla buttercream and white chocolate ganache

Gluten-Free Chocolate

Flourless chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream and dark chocolate ganache

Vegan Chocolate

Chocolate cake with cocoa frosting and dark cocoa glaze

Vegan Vanilla

Vanilla cake with vanilla frosting and white icing glaze